Quote
Pompon
I know that "too much exercise" can be bad.
The fact is we're not equal and "too much" for one may be "nearly negligible" for the other.
So, "too much" can obviously damage the heart (as often described) and lead to arrhythmias.
OTOH, "too much" can be far from what is usually described as "excessive". In my case, the only obvious effect years of "active" life and moderate exercise have had on my heart was bradycardia at rest (~50 BPM). And this (supposedly combined with genetics) has led me to AFib.
.
Clearly, there is a lot of variability. There are those who are chronically fit for life and never get afib (likely the majority). On one end of getting afib is:
Quote
splashrollandplod
Hi, I am 65 and I do triathlons (73 and counting) I’ve had symptomatic AF once 21 months ago - during a triathlon in Russia!
Source
On the other end is my 35 year old son-in-law. He's in the military, so required to be fit. Has run some half marathons, but not fanatical and presented with afib at age 30.
From the preface to the Haywire Heart book: "The sun shone bright on the upturned Flatirons rock formations above Boulder, Colorado. It was another perfect day in a cycling paradise. Lennard Zinn, a world-renowned technical cycling guru, founder of Zinn Cycles, author of Zinn and the Art of Road Bike Maintenance, longtime member of the VeloNews magazine staff, and former member of the US national cycling team, was riding hard up his beloved Flagstaff Mountain, a popular road that snakes over 4 miles and almost 2,000 feet above the city. It was a ride he had done a thousand times before. But on this day, in July 2013, his life would change forever. Fifteen minutes into his attempt to set a new Strava “king of the mountain” (KOM) time for the climb in the 55-plus age group, he felt his heart “skip” a beat. It was something he had felt before, but only at rest. He looked down at the Garmin computer on his handlebars and noticed that his heart rate had jumped from 155 to 218 beats per minute (bpm) and stayed elevated. He tapped the Garmin’s screen. Was the connection bad? He felt fine but eventually pulled the plug on the attempt, knowing that the distraction had disrupted any chance at a record. His heart rate immediately dropped, so he headed down the mountain to establish a different Strava segment KOM. His training plan called for a very hard ride, so he went to another climb and did a set of intervals. His ride completed, he headed home."
Case Christopher J.; Mandrola Dr. John; Zinn Lennard. The Haywire Heart: How too much exercise can kill you, and what you can do to protect your heart . VeloPress. Kindle Edition.
I was someplace in the middle. I'd always been fit, but not obsessive, and around the age of 41 decided to enter the Pikes Peak Ascent race (gains 7,800' over 13 1/3 miles topping out at 14,100'). I just wanted to finish, not compete to win anything. At age 49, after a training run for this race on a 14,000' peak, I had my first episode. I'd been competing annually.
What I know, in retrospect, is how much stress I was putting on my system. Years before I ever entered these races, my resting heart rate was easily in the low 40's. When I would finish a race, my resting heart rate would remain materially elevated for several days, then drop below normal and then finally returning to normal. After I had my first afib episode and before I decided to detrain and not compete, the period of below normal resting heart rate was a risk period for me.
After deciding that detraining needed to be part of my afib remission plan, I learned that for me, the product of intensity times time was a trigger (short, high intensity, i.e. Tabatas, OK, long, low intensity OK, long high intensity, not OK). I'd been exposed to the
work of John Douillard in the 90's & his
book.. Unfortunately, I had not followed his nasal breathing prescription when first exposed. However, I decided it was a decent place to start with detraining. For me, it worked. Later, I became aware of Patrick McKeown's breathing
work. It was Patrick's work that convinced me to
tape my mouth during sleep.
This detraining, along with electrolytes (magnesium to bowel tolerance, 4 g [2 tsp] of potassium as citrate in a liter of water consumed over the day & 2 g [1/2 tsp] taurine powder, and later, avoiding excess calcium in my diet) has allowed me to remain in relative afib remission for 16 1/2 years after an initial 2 1/2 month episode. [if you don't have good kidney function, don't play with electrolytes without medical supervision].
When I began helping my son-in-law with his afib, I wanted to quantify my detraining. It was then that I learned of Zone 2 as well as the MAF approach. In the Iñigo San Milán
interview on Z2, I learned that training at this modest intensity can increase mitochondrial density up to 4x as well as increasing mitochondrial size. My friend,
Dr. Mark Cucuzzella is a doc and runner who has been training using the MAF method for about 20 years. Mark calls his training "loafing." He says he always wants to end a run feeling better than when he started - i.e. more energy, not wiped out. In studying more about Z2, it turns out that most high end endurance athletes spend 80% of their training time in Z2 (now their Z2 may be higher than my maximum). Many recreational athletes spend most of their training time in more intense zones. Hence they never get the mitochondrial adaptation and likely incur much more stress.
My hypothesis is that if most recreational athletes spent most of their training time in Z2, we'd see much less afib in the group. Now once someone has afib, even Z2 may be too intense for some. All bets are off.
I have a friend who immigrated to the US from Morocco. He's a Berber (basically peasants living in rural villages). His village was around 30 miles from Marketch, in the foothills of the Atlas Mountains. His now 80+ year old father herded goats. He would leave early in the morning with the goats and follow them all day, up and down the steep hills and valleys, returning in the evening. T2 diabetes is rampant in his father's family. But his dad remains healthy do this day. An anecdote of spending the day being active, but not doing anything excessive. His father's goatherd friend, who was ~15 years older, was well and healthy till the day he passed. A testament to the lifestyle.
In the book, Dr. Mandrola does a good job of describing how folks with metabolic illness and the athletes with excessive training can end up with the same atrial substrate issues that allow afib to be sustained.